High Court Orders Restart of JB Marks Demarcation Process
Following a legal challenge brought forward by the Democratic Alliance (DA), the court set aside the board's previous refusal to split the municipality back into its original entities of Potchefstroom (formerly Tlokwe) and Ventersdorp.
Background of the Dispute
The JB Marks Local Municipality was formally established on August 3, 2016, through the amalgamation of the former Tlokwe City Council and the Ventersdorp Local Municipality. Since the merger, ongoing debates have persisted among residents and political representatives regarding service delivery, governance, and administrative efficiency across the combined region. In July 2025, the Municipal Demarcation Board resolved to retain the merged municipality, citing concerns over financial viability, administrative costs, resource sharing, and the potential destabilising effects of altering municipal boundaries.
The Court's Ruling
On August 28, 2026, the Democratic Alliance approached the High Court to have the MDB's decision reviewed and set aside. The opposition party argued that the board failed to adhere to mandatory public participation procedures before rejecting the demerger proposal.
In delivering the judgment, Acting Judge Vivian focused on Section 27 of the Local Government: Municipal Demarcation Act. This section empowers the board to hold public meetings, conduct a formal investigation, or do both after receiving initial written submissions. The court found that despite repeated recommendations to hold public meetings, including recommendations contained within the board's own formal investigation report, the MDB failed to consider this option and provided no reasons for doing so.
Acting Judge Vivian ruled that this omission constituted non-compliance with a material procedure under the Act, rendering the process unlawful. Consequently, the court set aside the decision to retain the unified municipality and ordered the MDB to pay the DA's legal costs.
Next Steps for Residents
Under the court's directive, the Municipal Demarcation Board must restart the boundary reconsideration process from Section 26 of the Municipal Demarcation Act. The upcoming statutory steps include:
Public Notification: The MDB must formally notify the public of its intention to reconsider the municipal boundaries between Potchefstroom and Ventersdorp.
Written Submissions: Residents and stakeholders will be granted a minimum window of 21 days to submit written representations and views.
Public Consultations: The board will be required to properly consider hosting public meetings to gather direct input from the affected communities.
Publication and Objections: Once a new determination is reached, the board must publish its decision in the Provincial Gazette, which will trigger a 30-day period for formal public objections.
DA Caucus Leader in JB Marks, Hans-Jurie Moolman, welcomed the ruling and urged residents to actively participate once the consultation window opens to ensure their perspectives are recorded. At the time of the ruling, the JB Marks Local Municipality had not yet confirmed whether it intends to appeal the High Court's decision.
The ruling reopens a decade-long debate over municipal boundaries in the North West province, placing public consultation back at the center of local governance. As the Municipal Demarcation Board prepares to initiate the statutory notice period, residents of both Potchefstroom and Ventersdorp will have a renewed opportunity to formally weigh in on the administrative future of their communities
#JBMarks #NorthWestNews #MunicipalDemarcation
⚖️ 🏛️ 🗺️ 📰
